When deciding on the best siding material for your home, the choices can seem overwhelming. Among the popular siding options, LP SmartSide and James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding stand out for their performance, aesthetics, and durability. Below, we compare these two top siding products, considering their benefits and drawbacks to help you make an informed decision for your next siding project.
LP SmartSide: Engineered Wood with a Modern Twist
What It Is:
LP SmartSide is a type of siding made from engineered wood strands treated with zinc borate to resist moisture intrusion, termite damage, and decay. It mimics the look of traditional wood siding, offering versatility for a range of styles, including shake siding and textured siding.
Pros:
- Quicker Installation: LP SmartSide’s lightweight design simplifies installation, reducing installation time and upfront costs.
- Natural Wood Appearance: The cedar texture of LP SmartSide provides a warm, authentic look that closely resembles real wood.
- Impact Resistance: Engineered wood fibers make this siding durable enough to withstand hail damage and harsh weather conditions.
- Affordability: LP SmartSide offers a lower initial cost compared to James Hardie, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners.
- Warranty Coverage: Backed by a 30-year non-prorated warranty, LP SmartSide ensures peace of mind for long-term performance.
Cons:
- Lower Fire Resistance: LP SmartSide does not perform as well as fiber cement siding products under high heat or exposure to ultraviolet light.
- Maintenance Requirements: The engineered wood material may require repainting or resealing over time to prevent moisture intrusion and damage from termites.
- Durability: While it resists fungal decay, it’s not as tough as fiber cement in areas prone to extreme weather or water damage.
James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding: Built for Longevity
What It Is:
James Hardie Industries pioneered fiber cement material, which combines wood pulp, cement, and sand. Known for its superior durability, Hardie board is one of the most robust siding materials available today, suitable for any type of siding project.
Pros:
- Unmatched Durability: With resistance to impact damage, carpenter ants, and even fire, James Hardie siding is engineered for harsh weather conditions and long-term performance.
- Minimal Maintenance Requirements: This fiber cement siding product resists stains and grime. Cleaning stubborn stains with a soft brush, mild detergent, and a garden hose is easy.
- Range of Styles: Choose from various designs, including board siding, vertical panels, and smooth finishes, to match your home’s unique look.
- Fire Resistance: Hardie board’s non-combustible nature ensures added safety, especially in fire-prone areas.
- Warranty Period: James Hardie provides a robust 30-year warranty on its siding products, offering long-lasting protection and value.
Cons:
- Heavier Material: Fiber cement siding is significantly heavier, increasing installation requirements and making it essential to opt for professional installation.
- Upfront Cost: The initial cost of materials and labor is higher compared to LP SmartSide.
- Installation Process: James Hardie requires precise cuts and expertise during installation to avoid cracking or damage.
Key Factors to Consider
- Durability vs. Affordability: If you’re seeking superior durability and minimal upkeep, James Hardie is a smart choice. For homeowners prioritizing affordability and quicker installation, LP SmartSide is an excellent alternative.
- Aesthetic Preferences: Both siding types offer a natural, wood-like appearance, but James Hardie boasts more style options and a smooth finish for a polished look.
- Climate Conditions: In areas prone to moisture intrusion or fire hazards, James Hardie’s fiber cement material offers better protection. Conversely, LP SmartSide’s lighter weight and zinc borate treatment make it ideal for moderate climates.
- Maintenance: LP SmartSide may require more frequent touch-ups, while James Hardie’s low maintenance requirements keep it looking great with minimal effort.
Choosing the Right Siding Professional
For any siding project, proper installation is key to ensuring your investment lasts. At Leading Edge Renovation, we specialize in both LP Smart Siding and James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding. Our experienced team can guide you through the types of siding available, ensuring your home benefits from the best solution for its needs and style.
Contact Leading Edge Renovation Today!
Ready to elevate your home with high-quality siding products? Call Leading Edge Renovation at (303) 862-0023 for a free consultation. Whether you’re drawn to the classic appeal of traditional wood siding or the durability of fiber cement products, our siding professionals ensure a seamless installation process. Let us help you create a beautiful, durable exterior that stands the test of time.